up it would go. Akiva heard the smile in her voice just before he saw it flicker over her face, fleet and fond. So I pretended to fall asleep one time, and I acted like I lost my soul and I made all the other kids help me look for it. All day, all over the peaks. She let the smile come out now, slow, extraordinary. I caught an air elemental and pretended it was my soul. Poor thing. What a little savage I was.
Her face, this face, Akiva realized, was still a mysterious land to him, and the smile almost made her a stranger.
If hed known Madrigal for a month of nights, hed known Karou for two nights? Or was it really one, through much of which hed slept, and two days in scattered pieces? Their few fraught meetings since, all hed seen of her was her rage, her devastation, her fear.
This was something else entirely. Smiling, she was as radiant as moonstone.
It struck him with force that he didnt really know her. It wasnt just her new face. He kept thinking of her as though she were Madrigal in a different body, but she was more than that. Shed lived another life since he knew herin another world, no less. How might it have changed her? He couldnt know.
But he could learn.
The pain of longing felt like a hole in the center of his chest. There was nothing in the worlds he wanted more than to start at the beginning and fall in love with Karou all over again.
That was a good day, she said, still lost in her long-ago memory.
How do you act like youve lost your soul? Akiva asked. He meant it as a lighthearted question about a childrens game, but when he heard himself say the words, he thought, Who knows better than I?
You betray everything you believe in. You drown your grief in vengeance. You kill and keep killing until theres no one left.
His expression must have betrayed his thoughts, because Karous smile shrank away. She was quiet for a long moment, meeting his look. Akiva had a lot to learn about her eyes, too. Madrigals had been warm brown. Summer and earth. Karous were black. They were sky-dark and star-bright, and when she looked at him like this, piercing, they seemed all pupil. Nocturnal. Unnerving.
She said, I can tell you how you act when you get your soul back , and he knew she wasnt talking about a game now. You save lives, she said. You let yourself dream again. Her voice dropped to a wisp. You forgive.
Silence. Held breath. Beating hearts. Was was she talking about him? Akiva felt the tilt of the world trying to tip him forward: to be nearer to hernearer and touchingas though that were the only state of rest, and every other action and movement were geared to achieving it.
She looked down, shy again. But you know better than I do. Im just starting.
You? You never lost your soul.
I lost something. While you were saving chimaera, I was making monsters for Thiago. I didnt know what I was doing. The same things I hated you for doing, but I couldnt see it
Its grief, said Akiva. Its rage. It makes us into the thing we despise. And he thought, And I was the thing you despised. Am I still? Its the fuel for everything our people have done to each other since the beginning. Thats what makes peace seem impossible. How can you blame someone for wanting to kill the killer of their loved ones? How can you fault people for what they do in grief?
As soon as he spoke the words, Akiva realized it sounded like he was excusing his own vicious grief spiral and its terrible toll on her people. Shame seized him. I dont mean I dont mean me . What I did, Karou, I know I can never atone for.
Do you really believe that? she asked. Her look was sharp, as though she were seeking through his shame for the truth.
Did he really believe it? Or was he just too guilt-ridden to admit he hoped that someday, somehow, he could atone? That someday he could feel that hed done more good than evil, and that by living he hadnt brought his world lower than if hed never been. Was that atonement, the tilt of the scales at the end of life?
If it was, then it might be possible. Akiva might, if he lived many years and never stopped trying, save more lives than he had destroyed.
But that wasnt what he believed, he realized, faced with the sharpness of Karous question. Yes, he said. I do. You cant atone for taking one life by saving another. What good does that do the dead?
The
dead, she said. And we have plenty of dead between us, but the way we act, youd think they were corpses hanging on to our ankles, rather than souls freed to the elements. She looked up at the chimney overhead, as though she were imagining the souls it had conducted in its time. Theyre gone, they cant be hurt anymore, but we drag their memory around with us, doing our worst in their name, like its what theyd want, for us to avenge them? I cant speak for all the dead, but I know its not what I wanted for you, when I died. And I know its not what Brimstone wanted for me, or for Eretz. Her gaze was still sharp, still piercing, nocturnal, black. It felt like recriminationof course shed wanted him to carry their dream forward, not find a way to destroy her peopleso when she said, Akiva, I never thanked you for bringing me Issas soul. I Im sorry for the things I said to you then it struck him with horror. The idea of her apologizing to him .